Having been defeated by a team of local footballers in the first encounter, two seasons ago, the cricketers were determined to restore some pride.
Opposing captains Tom Kidd and Tom Caddy provided solid captains knocks in the high-scoring encounter.
Despite adopting "backyard rules" and fielding 14 players, the footballers still fell short by 30 runs - 234 to 230.
The cricketers also scored bragging rights in the curtain-raiser U/19 match.